You said youd call me at 5

but you lied so obviously

I’m not the one on your mind

but i won’t cry

you have me so hypnotized

and it’s crazy but every word you say

i believe but you acted different

so distant and quick to leave

i know if i stay it will just cause more pain

but i cant let you go

Chorus

Baby why do you have to be so amazing to me

I try just to walk away

but your blue eyes make me stay

Baby you make this so confusing

either way I’m losing

baby why do you have to be so amazing to me

you said you hate to talk on the phone

so baby when i got home

and we were finally alone

all wrapped up in your arms in bed

you swore youd be here til the end

but its different now

and i dont know how

things got this way you seem so far away

and i know if i stay

it will just cause more pain

but i cant let you go

Chorus

Baby why do you have to be so amazing to me

I try just to walk away

but your blue eyes make me stay

Baby you make this so confusing

either way I’m losing

baby why do you have to be so amazing to me

It’s like I’m holding on to someone i don’t even know anymore

everythings changed

and your not the same

please come through that, through that door

Chorus

Baby why do you have to be so amazing to me

I try just to walk away

but your blue eyes make me stay

baby why cant you love me now

and leave no doubt baby

why do you have to be so amazing